I Pledge Allegiance . . .
The Indiana
legislature recently passed a bill which was signed into law by Governor
Daniels which requires a moment of silence in the morning in public schools where
people can silently pray, reflect on the upcoming day, daydream, etc.
It also requires the pledge of allegiance to be recited,
although students may opt out of it if they choose.
Both of my daughters are boat rockers, smart, head-strong (hard-headed),
not easily fooled or intimidated and not afraid to defend themselves.
Jessie, my youngest, a junior in high school has refused to
participate in the pledge. I support her
on this matter. First and foremost, it’s
lame. I said the pledge of allegiance as
a child, but was never asked to after third grade at most. If we had been instructed to do this in high
school the teacher would have been laughed out of the room. But times have changed and Indiana has gone so far red it’s surely in
the infrared spectrum now.
All has gone fairly well, though there has been taunting by
some self-appointed patriot police: “Oh, so you’re not an American. You’re not supporting the troops.” Etc.
Today Jessie responded with this: “The last time I had to
say the pledge of allegiance I was in like second grade, I was learning my ABC’s. Does that make you feel good to be doing
something that you stopped doing after you learned your ABC’s?” “Whatever” was all the patriot policeman
(Hitler Youth? Darn it, I swore I wasn’t going to use that term) could come
back with.
But yesterday a teacher told Jessie that she didn’t have to
say the pledge but that she had to stand.
That was not the way I understood the law. So I re-read it, contacted the Indiana Civil Liberties Union
and Deb has even contacted the Governors office to see if this is indeed
possible. My understanding is that
students could opt out. The governor’s
office is going to call back (probably) because that was their interpretation
too. The ICLU has responded that she is NOT required to stand by this law. Bless them. I'm glad I'm a member.
I want Jessie to be able to live with her conscience, but to
also be within the law.
This pledge thing will backfire. Eventually all high school students will come
to realize it’s pretty lame to do the same thing that they stopped doing in
kindergarten, and more students will opt out.
It will be embarrassing when they give the pledge and no one bothers.
Life would be easier for Jessie if she just did like
everyone else and robotically said the pledge.
But like I told her, a conscience is an expensive thing to have. You always have to pay. And like Ralph Waldo Emerson said: “Beware
when the great God lets loose a thinker on this planet.” Thinkers are scary. They make people (especially homeroom
teachers?) uncomfortable. People that
just get in line and do what they’re told aren’t so frightening.
One might ask why a father that served more than his fair
share of time in the military, takes his hat off and places his hand over his
heart and sings along with goose bumps on his back when the National Anthem is
played doesn’t encourage his daughter to say the pledge? Mainly because it’s lame and meaningless. It doesn’t support the troops. It doesn’t better America. It doesn’t ease the suffering of one
soul. It doesn’t cause one student to
become a better person. It’s lame. But it’s another American “quick fix”. We’re in the toilet as far as ethics in this
country. But let’s not look deeply into
the core and cause of that problem. Let’s
just say the pledge and that will ease our conscience.
That's Jessie, below.

Recent Comments